Efficient onboarding and workforce optimization is both essential and complex for state and territorial health departments. The intersection of intensifying public health emergencies and the rapidly changing landscape of public health necessitates a workforce that is robust, adaptable, and quickly integrated through effective onboarding processes. Nevertheless, these departments often face considerable challenges, such as administrative constraints, limited staffing, and process effectiveness, which can impede this process.
Amid these challenges, it is crucial to acknowledge that state and territorial health departments are not isolated in their struggles. The shared experiences of their counterparts in different jurisdictions or sectors can provide invaluable lessons. These collective narratives illuminate common challenges, spotlight successful strategies, and, most importantly, catalyze solutions. Onboarding and workforce optimization should not be perceived as merely procedural exercises but as transformative processes incorporating changes in administrative preparedness, innovative onboarding methodologies, and operational alterations to maximize efficiency.
By sharing experiences and learning from each other, state and territorial health departments can turn challenges into opportunities for enhancement, ensuring their onboarding procedures and workforce management remain flexible, resilient, and fully equipped to meet the dynamic demands of public health emergencies.
The journey toward building a robust and responsive public health workforce is a multifaceted task, made even more challenging during public health crises such as the COVID-19 pandemic. State and territorial health departments are often confronted with a variety of obstacles ranging from recruitment and onboarding to retaining qualified staff. One significant challenge is dealing with the uncertainties related to the duration of staff requirements, which is often unpredictable during a health crisis.
Legal and contractual constraints, including restrictive union contracts and stringent state hiring regulations, can further complicate these challenges. Such constraints can delay the swift hiring of necessary staff during crises and lead to complications in managing workforce expectations and planning. These factors can keep health agencies from being able to develop an efficient and resilient workforce equipped to respond effectively to public health emergencies.
Common contributing factors to these challenges include:
group_add
Recruitment challenges: Strict educational requirements may limit the available pool of potential workers, making it difficult to attract high-quality talent. Additionally, legal and contractual limitations can often delay the hiring process, particularly during emergencies, when rapid staffing is crucial.
supervised_user_circle
Onboarding issues: Inefficient and ineffective onboarding processes may leave new workers unprepared, slowing their integration into their roles. The uncertainty surrounding retraining or reassigning temporary pandemic staff to permanent roles adds another layer of complexity, potentially impacting the effective onboarding and integration of new hires.
running_with_errors
Structural barriers: Duration of staff requirement: The unpredictability of a crisis often makes it difficult to estimate how long an agency needs additional staff. This uncertainty can complicate hiring decisions and onboarding processes, leading to potential workforce instability and hampering effective emergency responses.
contract
Legal and contractual barriers: Union contracts and other state hiring mechanisms can make it difficult to quickly hire and onboard new staff. These legal limitations may result in delays and inefficiencies in the onboarding process, thereby contributing to workforce shortages during critical times of response.
This section highlights a successful and innovative solution your peers implemented to address challenges with workforce onboarding during public health emergencies. This story presents the factors that catalyzed the innovation, the existing policies or funding mechanisms that facilitated action, the potential barriers the agency faced, the collaborations and partnerships the agency leveraged, and tips for implementing and/or scaling the solution.
Navigating the Crisis: Illinois Health Department's Innovative Staffing Approach in the Face of COVID-19
Introduction
The Illinois Department of Public Health found itself in a challenging position early in the COVID-19 response. There was a pressing need for additional expertise, but union contracts and standard state hiring mechanisms threatened to delay the necessary increase in staffing. Recognizing this, the department leveraged its robust administrative preparedness practices to pivot its approach and focused on recruiting short-term contractual consultants. This strategy was made feasible by the additional funding streams dedicated to the COVID-19 response efforts.
Response to the Problem
At the heart of the department's strategy was an innovative, streamlined onboarding process. Traditional onboarding practices, designed for permanent employees, were set aside in favor of this new approach. These practices, rooted in the department's strong administrative preparedness, allowed new hires to be swiftly brought onboard and immediately contribute to the COVID-19 response.
Policies and Funding
The agency didn’t use existing programs or funding sources to recruit and onboard the new consultants, instead relying on the emergency funds allocated to handle the COVID-19 crisis.
Challenges and Solutions
The health department’s administrative preparedness plan was instrumental to circumventing potential roadblocks to hiring the consultants. Once the health department and the governor's office decided on the streamlined process, the health department swiftly put it into action. The solid foundation of administrative preparedness practices allowed the department to smoothly transition and adapt HR and contracting procedures to fit the needs of the crisis.
Collaborations and Partnerships
Although the health department didn’t report using direct partnerships for this process, the department did leverage it is extensive network of public health and healthcare professionals. This allowed the department to rapidly identify, recruit, and hire subject matter experts across the state who were either currently employed or recently retired.
Tips for Implementing and Scaling
Below are recommendations based on Illinois Department of Public Health’s experience:
- Develop or refine your department's administrative preparedness plan based on lessons learned during the COVID-19 response. This plan should be robust, flexible, and capable of meeting the dynamic needs of a public health emergency.
- Document provisions in the administrative preparedness plan that allow for waiving certain processes in extreme emergency situations. This ensures the plan can adapt to unexpected needs while maintaining effective operation.
APPLYING THIS KNOWLEDGE TO INFECTIOUS DISEASE
Illinois Department of Public Health’s strategic hiring practices can have the following potential benefits for infectious disease practice and policy:
- Efficient resource management: As demonstrated by the Illinois Department of Public Health, using a streamlined onboarding process can help departments rapidly integrate new hires, especially during emergencies such as infectious disease outbreaks. This speed and efficiency can help departments scale up their workforces and respond more effectively.
- Flexible hiring practices: By focusing on temporary contractual consultants, health departments can bypass potential bureaucratic delays tied to traditional hiring practices. This approach can be particularly beneficial when facing an infectious disease crisis that requires an immediate response.
- Adaptable policies: Having the ability to adapt or waive certain processes during emergencies, as outlined in an administrative preparedness plan, can allow health departments to respond more effectively to fast-paced, evolving situations such as infectious disease outbreaks.
- Effective networking: Leveraging the network of health department employees to recruit subject matter experts can expedite hiring during a crisis, providing an immediate boost to the department’s capacity to handle infectious disease emergencies.
- Optimized funding: Utilizing emergency funds or special funding streams for hiring and onboarding consultants can ensure that health departments have the resources they need during an infectious disease outbreak without having to divert funds from other important areas.
- Shared learning: Illinois Department of Public Health’s experience provides a roadmap for other departments facing similar challenges. By sharing their innovative approaches and lessons learned, they can help inform policies and practices across the public health sector.
This section encompasses a collection of pertinent tools and resources curated from ASTHO's Public Health Innovations Catalog and various other sources to help you navigate and comprehend the intricacies of this subject area. Garner insights and experiences from your peers, enabling you to start building solutions tailored to your health department.
Feeling inspired to address the unique challenges facing your department? With just one click, you can better understand your department's specific gaps and craft a persuasive action plan to present to your leadership and partners.
or explore the other focus areas:
Workforce Training & Resources Data Systems & Management Equity
Email the preparedness team with questions or comments.